Alexander Mikhailovich Shumlyansky (1748-1795): historiography

PHD Yurii Vasyliev1, Prof. Kostyantyn Vasyliev2

1Sumy State University, Sumy, Ukraine

2Odessa National Medical University

For the first time, a critical analysis of publications about Professor A.M. Shumlyansky was carried out for more than two centuries. Erroneous statements and errors are revealed; the gaps in Professor’s biography, which were subject to research, are indicated. The periodization of historiography is proposed. 1) Pre-Soviet period. In 1812 the first article about Professor was published. It is shown that the article has the character of a primary source, serving as the basis for the presentation of his subsequent biographies. 2) The Soviet period. During this period S.L. Sobol’s fundamental research saw the light. He introduced into scientific circulation and published a number of materials from the home archive of A.M. Shumlyansky. He described in detail his contribution to science. In this connection, he published a translation into Russian the second part of the Latin dissertation of Dr. Shumlyansky. 3) Post-Soviet period. On the one hand, a study appeared confirming the priority of Professor Shumlyansky, and on the other hand, an emphasis was placed on social history in the study of his biography.

Keywords: History of medicine, historiography, Poltava region, Ukraine, XVIII century, A.M. Shumlyansky

https://doi.org/10.15407/internalmed2023.01.028

Download.PDF (ukr)

Cite:

Васильєв, Ю.К. Олександр Михайлович Шумлянський (1748–1795): історіографія / Ю.К Васильєв, К.К. Васильєв // Східноєвропейський журнал внутрішньої та сімейної медицини. – 2023. – № 1. – С. 28-35. doi: 10.15407/internalmed2023.01.028

Vasyliev Y, Vasyliev K. Oleksandr Mykhailovych Shumlianskyi (1748–1795): istoriohrafiia / [Alexander Mikhailovich Shumlyansky (1748-1795): historiography]. Shidnoevr. z. vnutr. simejnoi med. 2023;1:28-35. Ukrainian. doi: 10.15407/internalmed2023.01.028

 References

  1. Belozerov IV, Rogozhin BA. Har’kovskij universitet i brat’ja Shumljanskie. Shіdnoеvropejs’kij zhurnal vnutrіshn’oі ta sіmejnoі 2021;2(B):6–10. Russian https://doi.org/10.15407/internalmed2021.02b.006
  2. Borodij NK K biografii brat’ev A.M. i P.M. Shumljanskih. Sovetskoe zdravoohranenie. 1984;7:66–68. Russian
  3. Volkov VA, Kulikova MV. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Moskovskaja professura XVIII — nachala XX veka. Estestvennye i tehnicheskie nauki. M.: Janus-K; 2003. 279 р. Russian
  4. Volkov VA, Kulikova MV. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Rossijskaja professura. XVIII — nachalo XX veka. Biologicheskie i mediko-biologicheskie nauki. Biograficheskij slovar’. SPb.; RHGI, 2003. 505 р. Russian
  5. Gusakov NI. K 200-letiju uchenija A.M.Shumljanskogo o pochke (1782–1982). Sovetskaja medicina. 1983;4:117–119. Russian
  6. Dmitrieva ZV. K voprosu o prioritete otechestvennyh uchenyh. A.M. Shumljanskogo i ego rabota po izucheniju mikroskopicheskogo stroenija pochki. Zdravoohranenie Kazahstana. 1953;3:33–34. Russian
  7. Dudchenko MA. Aleksandr Mihajlovich Shumljanskij. Klinicheskaja medicina. 1983;1;114–116. Russian
  8. Zmeev LF. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Russkie vrachi-pisateli. SPb., 1886. Tetrad’ 2. 169 р. Russian
  9. Ivanov NI. Nauchnoe znachenie raboty A.M.Shumljanskogo «O stroenii pochki». Sovetskaja medicina. 1950;9:35–37. Russian
  10. Krishtopa BP. Shumljans’kij Oleksandr Mihajlovich. Kiеvo-Mogiljans’ka akademіja v і XVII—XVIII st. K.; 2001. Р 594–595. Russian
  11. Morgoshija TSh, Beljaeva DO. Vklad A.M. Shumljanskogo (1748–1795) v klinicheskuju medicinu — odnogo iz osnovopolozhnikov nefrologii i mikroskopicheskoj anatomii v Rossii (k 225-letiju so dnja smerti professora). Klinicheskaja nefrologija. 2020;4:80–83. Russian https://doi.org/10.18565/nephrology.2020.4.80-83
  12. Nikitin AN. Shumljanskij Aleksandr. Kratkij obzor sostojanija mediciny v Rossii v carstvovanie imperatricy Ekateriny II. SPb;1855. Р 66–67. Russian
  13. Olejnik S.F. K otkrytiju kapsuly Shumljanskogo. Klinicheskaja medicina. — 1952;6:89–91. Russian
  14. Pavlovskij IF. Shumljanskij, Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Kratkij biograficheskij slovar’ uchenyh i pisatelej Poltavskoj gubernii s poloviny XVIII veka. Poltava; 1912. Р Russian
  15. Palkin BN. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Russkie gospital’nye shkoly XVIII veka i ih vospitanniki. M.:Medgiz; 1959. 241 р. Russian
  16. Serebrennikov V. Kievskaja akademija s poloviny XVIII veka do preobrazovanija ejo v 1819 g. Kiev; 1897. 223 р. Russian
  17. Serkov AI. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Russkoe masonstvo. 1731–2000 gg. Jenciklopedicheskij slovar’. : ROSSPJeN; 2001. 916 р. Russian
  18. Sobol’ SL. Istorija mikroskopa i mikroskopicheskih issledovanij v Rossii v XVIII veke. ; L.; 1949. Р 389–396. Russian
  19. Sobol’ SL. Osnovopolozhnik otechestvennoj gistologii A.M. Shumljanskij (1748–1795). Nauchnoe nasledstvo. Estestvennonauchnaja serija. : iz-vo AN SSSR; 1951. T.2. Р 401–481. Russian
  20. Sobol’ SL. Aleksandr Mihajlovich Shumljanskij (1748– 1795). Ljudi russkoj nauki. Ocherki o vydajushhihsja dejateljah estestvoznanija i tehniki. M.: iz-vo fiziko-matematicheskoj literatury; 1963. 3. Р 45–55. Russian
  21. Speranskij VS. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Bol’shaja medicinskaja jenciklopedija. 3-e iz-nie. M.: Sovetskaja jenciklopedija; 1986. 27.  498 р. Russian
  22. Suslov VV, Gusakov NI. K 200-letiju uchenija A.M. Shumljanskogo o pochke (1782–1982). Urologija i nefrologija. 1983;1:61–64. Russian
  23. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Russkij biograficheskij slovar’. SPb.; 1911.  T.: Shebanov. Shjutc. 538 р. Russian
  24. Hrzhonshhevskij NA. Issledovanie jepitelija legochnyh puzyr’kov, pecheni, pochek i limfaticheskih sosudov pomoshh’ju fiziologicheskoj in”ekcii. Protokoly zasedanij Obshhestva russkih vrachej v S.-Peterburge. SPb.; 1864–1865. 31 god. Р 51–74. Russian
  25. Chistovich JaO. Shumljanskij Aleksandr Mihajlovich. Istorija pervyh medicinskih shkol v Rossii. Peterburg; 1883. Р SSSXLII – SSSXLIV. Russian
  26. Shpachinskij NA. Kievskij mitropolit Arsenij Mogiljanskij i sostojanie Kievskoj mitropolii v ego pravlenie (1757—1770). Kiev;1907.  XII, 667 р. Russian
  27. Shumljanskij AM. O stroenii pochek. Istorija mikroskopa i mikroskopicheskih issledovanij v Rossii v XVIII veke. M.; L., 1949. Р 519–558. Russian
  28. Gottschalk CW. Alexander Schumlansky’s De structura renum. American Journal of Nephrology. 1994. 14. P. 320–324. https://doi.org/10.1159/000168742
  29. Kelchen JH. de. Plan de l’École Impériale medicochirurgicale. P.; 1786.  Р. 10.