Medical education against the backdrop of war: the case of Karazin University

Posted on by adminLeave a comment

Prof. Tetiana Liadova, asst. Maksym Kyrychenko, аssoc. prof. Anatoliy Babichev,  prof. Olena Protsenko, аssoc. prof. Natalia Remnyova

V.N. Karazin Kharkiv National University

The article examines the global experience of the impact of military conflicts on medical education, with particular attention to the experience of Karazin University School of Medicine. It concludes that the impact of war on medical education is extremely negative and has always been characterized by interruptions or deterioration of learning conditions, its reorientation to meet war needs, the worsening physical and psychological state of students, and a decrease in the effectiveness of their learning.

These factors pose a threat not only to education but also to the nation as a whole, as the decline in the quality of medical education creates a shortage of personnel in the healthcare system, which is critically needed during war and in post-wartime. Nevertheless, the Karazin University School of Medicine has met the challenges of wartime with dignity and managed to organize the education of medical students in both online and in-person formats, as well as to establish open courses for developing primary medical care skills for the wounded and those affected by the consequences of the war.

Key words: war, medical education, Karazin University, education during war, student well-being, stress.

https://doi.org/10.15407/internalmed2024.02.004

Download.PDF (укр)

Cite:

Лядова, Т.І. Медична освіта на тлі війни: приклад Каразінського університету / Т.І. Лядова, М.І. Кириченко, А.В. Бабічев, О.С. Проценко, Н.О. Ремньова // Східноєвропейський журнал внутрішньої та сімейної медицини. – 2024. – № 2. – С. 4-16. http://doi.org/10.15407/internalmed2024.02.004

Liadova TI, Kyrychenko MI, Babichev AV, Protsenko OS, Remnyova NO. [Medical education against the backdrop of war: the case of Karazin University]. Shidnoevr. z. vnutr. simejnoi med. 2024;2:4-16. Ukrainian. http://doi.org/10.15407/internalmed2024.02.004

References:

  1. AlSaadi T., ZaherAddeen S., Turk T., Abbas F., Alkhatib M.Psychologicaldistressamongmedicalstudentsinconflicts:a cross-sectionalstudyfromSyria // BMC MedicalEducation. — 2017. — № 17. — P. 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-017-1012-2.
  2. Alsabri M., Alsakkaf L. M., Alhadheri A., Cole J., Burkle F.M. Jr. ChronicHealthCrisesandEmergencyMedicineinWar-tornYemen, Exacerbatedbythe COVID-19 Pandemic// TheWesternJournalofEmergencyMedicine. —2022. — № 23(2). — Р. 276–84. https://doi.org/10.5811/westjem.2021.10.51926.
  3. Alverez W. C. MedicaleducationandpracticeinGermanyduringWorldWar II // Gastroenterology. — 1946. № 7(4). —P. 493–494.
  4. Andrews J. S., Lomis K. D., Richardson J. A., Hammoud M. M.,Skochelak S. E. Expandinginnovationfromundergraduatetograduatemedicaleducation: A pathofcontinuousprofessionaldevelopment // MedicalTeacher. — 2021. № 43(sup2). —Р. 49–55. https://doi.org/10.1080/0142159x.2021.1935835.
  5. Antoniuk V. PerspectiveChapter: TheWaras a FactorofUpheavalsandTransformationsinHigherEducation —ExperienceofUkraine // EducationandHumanDevelopment/ ed. Waller, S. KayWaller: IntechOpen, 2023. https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.109688.
  6. Chauhan V., Secor-Jones S., Paladino L., Sardesai I., RatnayakeA., Stawicki S. P., etal. EmergencyDepartments: Preparingfora NewWar // JournalofEmergencies, Trauma, andShock. —2022. — № 15(4). — Р. 157–161. https://doi.org/10.4103/jets.jets_143_22.
  7. Chu H. P. Medicaleducationduringtheanti-aggressionwar //ChineseMedicalJournal. — 1946. — № 64(1–2). — Р. 17–23.
  8. Crofton E. MedicalstudentsinthefirstWorldWar: theEdinburghexperience // TheJournaloftheRoyalCollegeofPhysiciansofEdinburgh. — 1997. — № 27(2). — Р. 227–241.
  9. Debarre A. Hardtoreach: providinghealthcareinarmedconflict. InternationalPeaceInstitute. — 2018. — 40 р.
  10. Diehl H. S. MedicalEducation // TheAnnalsoftheAmericanAcademyofPoliticalandSocialScience. — № 231(1). —Р. 88–92. https://doi.org/10.1177/000271624423100115.
  11. Dobiesz V. A., Schwid M., Dias R. D., Aiwonodagbon B., TayebB., Fricke A., etal. Maintaininghealthprofessionaleducationduringwar: A scopingreview// MedicalEducation. —2022. — № 56(8). — Р. 793–804. https://doi.org/10.5195/ijms.2023.2476.
  12. Editorial // BritishMedicalJournal. — 1915. — № 1. — Р. 977.https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.1.2840.977.
  13. Editorial // BritishMedicalJournal. — 1915. — № 2. — Р. 785.https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.2865.785.
  14. BritishMedicalJournal // BritishMedicalJournal. —1914. — № 2. — P. 307-312. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.2797.307.
  15. Fares J., Fares M. Y., Fares Y. Medicalschoolsintimesofwar:Integratingconflictmedicineinmedicaleducation // SurgicalNeurologyInternational. — 2020. — № 11. — Р. 5. https://doi.org/10.25259/sni_538_2019.
  16. Garfield R., McCarthy C. F. NursingandnursingeducationinIraq: challengesandopportunities // InternationalNursingReview. — 2005. № 3 (52). — Р. 180–185. doi:10.1111/j.1466-7657.2005.00428.
  17. Ghobarah H. A., Huth P., Russett B. Thepost-warpublichealtheffectsofcivilconflict // SocialScience&Medicine. — 2004. —№ 59 (4), — Р. 869–884. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2003.11.043.
  18. Gisondi M. A., Michael S., Li-Sauerwine S., Brazil V., Caretta-Weyer H. A., Issenberg B., etal. ThePurpose, Design, andPromiseofMedicalEducationResearchLabs // AcademicMedicine. — 2022. –№ 97(9). — Р. 1281–1288. https://doi.org/10.1097/acm.0000000000004746.
  19. Hoefer R. A. Jr, Maris C. R., Silver L. F., Jennings M. J. Trainingresidentsurgeonsincombat: anexperienceduringthePersianGulfWar // MilitaryMedicine. — 1992. — № 157(12). —Р. 657–659. doi:10.1093/milmed/157.12.657.
  20. Le T.-H., Bui M.-T., Uddin G. S. Economicandsocialimpactsofconflict: A cross-countryanalysis // EconomicModelling. —2022. — № 115. — Р. 105980. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2022.105980.
  21. Madsen A. M., Pope R., Samuels A., Margolis C. Z. Foreignstudentsexperienceduring a timeofwar // TheIsraelMedicalAssociationJournal. — 2013. — № 15(3). — Р. 143–147.
  22. Mushtaha E., AbuDabous S., Alsyouf I., Ahmed A., RaafatAbdraboh N. Thechallengesandopportunitiesofonlinelearningandteachingatengineeringandtheoreticalcollegesduringthepandemic // AinShamsEngineeringJournal. —2022. — № 13(6). — Р. 101770. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asej.2022.101770.
  23. Srichawla B. S., KhazeeiTabari M. A., Gaman M. A., Munoz-Valencia A., Bonilla-Escobar F. J. WaronUkraine: ImpactonUkrainianMedicalStudents // InternationalJournalofMedicalStudents. — 2022. — № 10(1). — Р. 15–17. https://doi.org/10.5195/ijms.2022.1468.
  24. Takoutsing B. D., Găman M. A., Puyana J. C., Bonilla-EscobarF. TheSilentCasualties: War’sImpactonMedicalStudentsandMedicalEducation // InternationalJournalofMedicalStudents. — 2023. — № 11(4). — Р. 254–258. https://doi.org/10.5195/ijms.2023.2476.
  25. Turk T., Aboshady O. A., Albittar A. Studying medicine incrisis: students perspectives from Syria // Medical Teacher. —2016. — № 38(8). — Р. 861–862. doi:10.1080/0142159X.2016.1204432.
  26. Anesteziolohynia Mariia Matvieienko: «U profesii zalyshaiutsia naibilsh stresostiiki». Rozmova pro nahorodu vid Chervonoho Khresta ta pro pochatok viiny. Karazinskyi universytet. 24 Feb 2024.
  27. Belozerov Y. V., Posokhov S. Y., Protsenko E. S., Kyrychenko M. Y. Medytsynskyi fakultet Karazynskoho unyversyteta 1805–1920 hodov / pod obshch. red. Y. V. Belozerova. — Kharkiv: KhNU imeni V. N. Karazina, 2020. — 336 s.
  28. Biblioteka Kharkivskoho universytetu: realii viiny. Karazinskyi universytet. 1 Oct 2023.
  29. Viina ne pereshkoda: chomu inozemni studenty obyraiut Karazinskyi. Karazinskyi universytet. 24 Feb 2024
  30. Volonterska dopomoha za initsiatyvy inozemnykh studentiv medychnoho fakultetu. [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/827-volonterskadopomogaza-initsiativi-inozemnih-studentiv-medichnogofakultetu.
  31. Heimanovych A. Nykolai Fedotovych Melnykov-Razvedenkov // Yubyleinyi sbornyk v chest profesora N.F. Melnykova-Razvedenkova po povodu 25-letyia eho nauchno-prepodavatelskoi deiatelnosty. — T. 1. — Kharkov, 1916.
  32. Dekanesa medychnoho fakultetu, profesorka Tetiana Liadova: «Universytet zhyve, navchaie, tvoryt zarady peremohy!». Karazinskyi universytet. 17 Nov 2023
  33. Zberihaiemo vohnyk nadii v nashykh viknakh: reportazh z vidnovlennia Karazinskoho universytetu. Karazinskyi universytet. 29 Jan 2023
  34. Zustrich karazintsiv z predstavnykamy universytetu Rehensburha. Karazinskyi universytet. 24 Feb 2024.
  35. Karazinskyi vidkryv novu klinichnu bazu medychnoho fakultetu — DU «Instytut patolohii khrebta ta suhlobiv imeni profesora M. I. Sytenka NamnUkrainy». Karazinskyi universytet. 6 Dec 2023.
  36. Karazinskyi nahaduie pro mozhlyvist navchatysia popry vidkliuchennia svitla [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: https://karazin.ua/news/karazinskyi-nahaduie-pro-nbspmozhlyvistbezpechno-navchatys/.
  37. Karazinskyi svit nauky-2023. Karazinskyi universytet. 1 Nov
  38. Karazintsi rozpochaly navchannia v universyteti Rehensburha za prohramoiu obminu. Karazinskyi universytet. —29 Dec 2023.
  39. Lesovoi V. N., Tsymbal M. L., Pertseva Zh. N., Olkhovskyi V. A. Otets i syn Bokaryusy: zhyzn, otdannaia sudebnoi medytsyne // UNIVERSITATES. Nauka y prosveshchenye: nauchno–populiarnyi zhurnal. 2009;2:12–23.
  40. Maister-klas «Persha dopomoha pry travmi / InitialTraumaManagement (ITM)». [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/970-mayster-klaspershadopomoga-pri-travmi-Initial-Trauma-ManagementITM.
  41. Maister-klas dlia uchniv vid Karazinskoi shkoly nevidkladnoi ta taktychnoi medytsyny. [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/954-maysterklasdlya-uchniv-vid-karazinskoi-shkoli-nevidkladnoi-tataktichnoimeditsini.
  42. Maister-klas z fizychnoi terapii ta reabilitatsii «Instrumentalna mobilizatsiia miakykh tkanyn i perkusiinyi masazh v reabilitatsii viiskovosluzhbovtsiv. Tekhniky i praktychne zastosuvannia». [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/963-maysterklas-z-fizichnoi-terapii-ta-reabilitatsii-Instrumentalnamobilizatsiya-myakih-tkanin-i-perkusiyniy-masaj-vreabilitatsii-viyskovoslujbovtsiv-tehniki-i-praktichnezastosuvannya.
  43. Metroshkola u kozhnomu raioni? Robota naukovo-osvitnoho klasteru v Karazinskomu. Dyskusiia pro navchannia pid zemleiu. Karazinskyi universytet. 17 Apr 2024.
  44. Naikrashchyi i naibilshyi symuliatsiinyi tsentr v Ukraini — medychnoho fakultetu Karazinskoho universytetu. Karazinskyi universytet. 1 Oct 2023.
  45. Nebesni karazintsi. Karazinskyi universytet. 24 Feb 2024.
  46. Obshchyi ustav Ymperatorskykh Rossyiskykh unyversytetov. — Kharkov: v unyversytetskoi typohrafyy, 1837. 50 p.
  47. Otchet Lazareta dlia ranenykh voynov Kharkovskoho medytsynskoho obshchestva y Vserossyiskoho soiuza horodov N4 (9-ho oktiabria 1914 g. — 1-ho yiulia 1916 g.). Kharkov. medytsyn. o-vo. Kharkov : Typ. Ya. Y. Namoiter, 1917. 168 p.
  48. Otchet o sostoianyy lazareta Ymperatorskoho Kharkovskoho unyversyteta dlia ranenykh voynov so dnia eho otkrytyia 26 oktiabria 1914 hoda po 1 yanvaria 1915 hoda. Kharkov.Ymp. un-t. Kharkov, Typohrafyia fyrmы «Adolf Darre»,1915. 40 p.
  49. Pratsiuiemo zarady maibutnoho! Karazinskyi universytet. 29 Jan 2024.
  50. Prohrama navchannia dlia studentiv medychnoho fakultetu z Niherii. [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/802-programa-navchannya-dlyastudentiv-medichnogo-fakultetu-z-nigerii.
  51. Protsenko E. S., Kyrychenko M. Y., Remnёva N. A., Padalko V. Y. Kafedra obshchei y klynycheskoi patolohyy: ot ystokov k sovremennosty: monohrafyia / pod. red. V. N. Savchenko. Kharkiv, KhNU imeni V. N. Karazyna, 2016. 188 p.
  52. Sokolov N. A. Kafedra hospytalnoi khyrurhycheskoi klynyky. Medytsynskyi fakultet Kharkovskoho unyversyteta za pervye 100 let eho sushchestvovanyia (1805–1905). Pod red. Y. P. Skvortsova, D. Y. Bahaleia. Kharkov: Pechatnoe delo, 1905–1906. — P. 357–371.
  53. Spivpratsia Tsentru pisliadyplomnoi medychnoi osvity ta pozashtatnoi hrupy fizychnoi terapii ta reabilitatsii viiskovoho uhrupovannia «Kharkiv». [Elektronnyi resurs]Rezhym dostupu: https://cpo.karazin.ua/фізична-терапія-та-реабілітація.
  54. Stomatolohichna osvita znovu v Karazinskomu! Karazinskyi universytet. 29 Dec 2023.
  55. Studenty 3 kursu ukrainomovnoi formy navchannia vidviduiut patolohoanatomichnyi muzei. [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/989-patolohoanatomichnyi-muzei.
  56. Treninh «Bazovi med sestrynski navychky». [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/980-trening-bazovi-medsestrinski-navichki.
  57. Treninh «Nevidkladni stany: nadannia domedychnoi dopomohy na mistsi podii». [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/923-trening-nevidkladnistani-nadannya-domedichnoi-dopomogi-na-mistsi-podiy.
  58. Treninh z osnov taktychnoi medytsyny dlia voiniv Zbroinykh syl Ukrainy. [Elektronnyi resurs] Rezhym dostupu: http://medicine.karazin.ua/news/931-trening-z-osnov-taktichnoimeditsini-dlya-voiniv-zbroynih-sil-ukraini.
  59. Kharkovskoe Medytsynskoe Obshchestvo. Kharkovskyi medytsynskyi zhurnal. 1916, Tom 20, P. 438.
  60. Voina. Kharkovskyi medytsynskyi zhurnal. 1914; 18:212–214.
  61. Tsykl ochnykh zaniat z fiziolohii dlia studentiv-medykiv zghidno z memorandumom pro spivrobitnytstvo z universytetom Rehensburha. Karazinskyi universytet. 3 May 2024.